I picked up this book at the Sapna Bookstore in Bangalore last year during Christmas vacation and read the book in a couple of days. I could not find many interesting books when I went book shopping that day. This book caught my eye, as, mystery novels woven in Hyderabad are not common, and since I live in Hyderabad, I was drawn to it instantly.
The book consists of 2 different stories- The Sonia Sinha case and the Mysterious Affair of the Lohia Mansion. The common factor is a former cop Vikram Rana, who leaves the force and starts his private investigation agency. The Lohia mansion case is the first case he investigates. The other common factor is inspector Reddy who is 'formally' investigating the case in both the stories. There is a brief description about Vikram's wife as well, who plays a bit of a role in Vikram's character building in the eyes of the readers.
Vikram Rana bags his first case when his friend hires him to investigate the murder of his sister-in- law, a socialite in Hyderabad who dies under mysterious circumstances in the Lohia mansion. The story obviously revolves around how Vikram resolves the mystery.
The second case that is brought to Vikram is by Mrs. Raju who wants to prove her son (a suspect), innocent in the murder of her husband. He is awarded this case based on his famed resolution of the Lohia mansion case. This story is about how Vikram reveals the true murderer in the case. Of course, he takes support from Inspector Reddy.
The writing style is quite casual. The book is fast paced and easy to read. There are a few spelling mistakes which seems to have not been at the time of editing. There are some irrelevant descriptions in the book. Example- about autodriver woes in Hyderabad- does not help readers make a connection, is completely irrelevant and does not contribute to anything in the story; and an irrelevant quote by Groucho Marx when Vikram meets Gaurav, a character in the Lohia mansion story. Certain things are stated quite directly and plainly, where making it more experiential would have been nicer. Also, some sentences seem as passing narrations without any proper basis. As an example- Full lips are a symbol of fertility, seems a little far-fetched. The chronology of events in terms of dates in the Sonia Sinha case are quite messed up and a complete put off.
I liked the descriptions of food in the book and references of different localities in Hyderabad. It makes it very relatable to the Hyderabadis. The non-Hyderabadis or those in RR district of Hyderabad may find it a little difficult to relate to all the places mentioned. However, I appreciate the author's effort in painting a picture of Hyderabad in the minds of such readers.
Since this is the writer's first book, I sincerely appreciate her effort, as, in the current generation of writers, we do not have too many Indians venturing into this genre of writing- crime, thriller and mystery. This is a difficult genre to write and requires a lot more research, perspective and understanding on means, method, psychology, deduction than writing a drama or a love story. However, I would rate it 2 on a scale of 5. The main reason being the predictability of the culprits of the the crimes committed. It just happens too early in the story and I did not have the 'What!!" or "Aaaahhh!!" moments in both the stories when the culprits are revealed which generally happens with good mystery novels. The writer made it too obvious, especially in the Sonia Sinha case and one could easily figure out the murderer very early in the story and the only reason I read it was to understand the motive behind the murder, which I lost interest in once it was obvious who the murderer was. I like mystery novels where we are kept guessing on the murderer until the very end.
I hear the writer's second book is out already and I will definitely pick it up- I actually looked for it but could not find it in bookstores. I would like to encourage more Indians to write in this genre and I surely hope and have gut feeling that the second book would be way better than the first. Wishing her all the best and look forward to reading the next book.
The book consists of 2 different stories- The Sonia Sinha case and the Mysterious Affair of the Lohia Mansion. The common factor is a former cop Vikram Rana, who leaves the force and starts his private investigation agency. The Lohia mansion case is the first case he investigates. The other common factor is inspector Reddy who is 'formally' investigating the case in both the stories. There is a brief description about Vikram's wife as well, who plays a bit of a role in Vikram's character building in the eyes of the readers.
Vikram Rana bags his first case when his friend hires him to investigate the murder of his sister-in- law, a socialite in Hyderabad who dies under mysterious circumstances in the Lohia mansion. The story obviously revolves around how Vikram resolves the mystery.
The second case that is brought to Vikram is by Mrs. Raju who wants to prove her son (a suspect), innocent in the murder of her husband. He is awarded this case based on his famed resolution of the Lohia mansion case. This story is about how Vikram reveals the true murderer in the case. Of course, he takes support from Inspector Reddy.
The writing style is quite casual. The book is fast paced and easy to read. There are a few spelling mistakes which seems to have not been at the time of editing. There are some irrelevant descriptions in the book. Example- about autodriver woes in Hyderabad- does not help readers make a connection, is completely irrelevant and does not contribute to anything in the story; and an irrelevant quote by Groucho Marx when Vikram meets Gaurav, a character in the Lohia mansion story. Certain things are stated quite directly and plainly, where making it more experiential would have been nicer. Also, some sentences seem as passing narrations without any proper basis. As an example- Full lips are a symbol of fertility, seems a little far-fetched. The chronology of events in terms of dates in the Sonia Sinha case are quite messed up and a complete put off.
I liked the descriptions of food in the book and references of different localities in Hyderabad. It makes it very relatable to the Hyderabadis. The non-Hyderabadis or those in RR district of Hyderabad may find it a little difficult to relate to all the places mentioned. However, I appreciate the author's effort in painting a picture of Hyderabad in the minds of such readers.
Since this is the writer's first book, I sincerely appreciate her effort, as, in the current generation of writers, we do not have too many Indians venturing into this genre of writing- crime, thriller and mystery. This is a difficult genre to write and requires a lot more research, perspective and understanding on means, method, psychology, deduction than writing a drama or a love story. However, I would rate it 2 on a scale of 5. The main reason being the predictability of the culprits of the the crimes committed. It just happens too early in the story and I did not have the 'What!!" or "Aaaahhh!!" moments in both the stories when the culprits are revealed which generally happens with good mystery novels. The writer made it too obvious, especially in the Sonia Sinha case and one could easily figure out the murderer very early in the story and the only reason I read it was to understand the motive behind the murder, which I lost interest in once it was obvious who the murderer was. I like mystery novels where we are kept guessing on the murderer until the very end.
I hear the writer's second book is out already and I will definitely pick it up- I actually looked for it but could not find it in bookstores. I would like to encourage more Indians to write in this genre and I surely hope and have gut feeling that the second book would be way better than the first. Wishing her all the best and look forward to reading the next book.
No comments:
Post a Comment